Welcome to Witherspoon on the Web       

News and networking for progressive Presbyterians

Home page

Ordination concerns

Immigrant rights

War on Iraq

Search Archive
2006 General Assembly Global & Social concerns Election 2008 Israel & Palestine About us Just for fun

News of the PC(USA)

Torture --
It's time to resist!
Other churches, other faiths War on Iran?? Join us! Notes from your WebWeaver

What's Where

Our reports about the
2008 General Assembly

You'll find much more on the GA at JustPresbys -- the shared website of 6 progressive Presbyterian organizations.

ABOUT US

The Spring 2008 issue of
Network News
is posted here
- in Adobe PDF format.

Click here for earlier issues
Adobe PDF  Click here to download (free!) Adobe Reader software to view this and all PDF files.

News of the Society
How to join us
Witherspoon's
Global Engagement Initiative
Dancing with God -- reports from the 2005 Witherspoon conference on mission for peace and justice

SEARCH

CONNECTIONS

Coming events calendar 

Do you want to announce an event?
Please send a note!
Food for the spirit
Book notes

Go to  Amazon.com

LINKS

NEWS of the Presbyterian Church

Got news??
Send us a note!
Women's Concerns
Social and global concerns
The Middle East conflict
The War in Iraq
Hurricane Katrina
U. S. Politics
Election 2008
Economic justice
Fair Food Campaign
Sexual justice
Peacemaking & international concerns
Caring for the environment
Immigrant rights
Racial concerns
Church & State
The death penalty
The media
OTHER CHURCHES, OTHER FAITHS
Do you want regular e-mail updates when stories are added to our web site?
Just send a note!
The WebWeaver's Space
ARCHIVES
JUST FOR FUN
Want books?
Search Now:

 

The limits of health care: the Schiavo case

A prayer on the death of Terri Schiavo   [3-31-05]

Charles Henderson, a Presbyterian minister and “Your Guide to Christianity – General” on About.com, offers this prayer of gratitude for the gift of life, and a releasing of the loved one into the hands of God.

God of compassion and love,
you have breathed into us the breath of life
and have given us minds and bodies in which we live out
our days on earth.

For the gift of life, we are grateful.

We humbly acknowledge that there is a time to live,
and a time to die.

We commit this life* to you,
trusting in your gracious promises and
confident in the sure and certain hope of new
life in the world to come.

Into your hands we commit our beloved.
May your will be done!

In the good and gracious name of Christ,
we pray. Amen.

* the name of a loved one may be used here.

You can also read it on Henderson's web site >>

Other good resources from Dr. Henderson:

bullet a lengthy essay on the “right to die" >>
 
bullet a lawyerly survey of the legal issues in the Schiavo case >>

Scroll down for more on the dying of Terri Schiavo

Personal Reflections on Theresa Schiavo's Life

The Rev. C. Welton Gaddy, president of The Interfaith Alliance, has written a personal expression of concern – for Terri Schiavo and her family, and for the political climate in our nation today.   [3-25-05]

A few excerpts:

The life-and-death issues brought into focus by Mrs. Schiavo’s sad condition involve medical questions and legal considerations far too complex for me to address without more information. I might add that, in my opinion, members of the United States Congress would have been well advised to adopt a posture of humility and compassion related to these issues as they impact Mrs. Schiavo and her family. ...

Profound questions disturb me. Are there no limits on the intrusive reach of this government? Where will Washington go next? Do claims of both religious and political authority give a government the right to invade the spheres of personal autonomy and religious independence? How long will the American public wait for such questions to be answered.

Dear friends, all of us would do well to step back from the bedside of a woman caught somewhere between death and life, divorce our political initiatives from this realm of personal and familial pain, pray for the peace of Terri Schiavo and her family, and ... decide what we are going to do about our democracy.

Read his letter in full >>

QUOTE OF THE WEEK

"The case is full of great ironies. A large part of Terri's hospice costs are paid by Medicaid, a program that the administration and conservatives in Congress would sharply reduce. Some of her other expenses have been covered by the million-dollar proceeds of a malpractice suit - the kind of suit that President Bush has fought to scale back."              [3-25-05]

- NPR commentator Daniel Schorr.       [with thanks to Stuart Robertson]

Ten Native Americans die, and there is silence

[a little comment from your WebWeaver]

As residents of Minnesota, we may feel a little closer to the killings and suicide in Red Lake, just a couple hundred miles north of the Twin Cities.  And we do wonder about a sense of proportion.  Ten people -- men, women, and teen-agers -- are dead, and a tightly connected Native American community is deeply affected.  And from the White House, not a word.  For one white woman, slowly dying in Florida after years of unconsciousness, the White House and Congress have tried to move heaven and earth -- or at least the state and federal courts, including even the Supremes -- to extend the life of Terri Schiavo's body a bit longer.  Why?

Clyde Bellecourt, a Chippewa Indian who is the founder and national director of the American Indian Movement here in the Twin Cities, is quoted in a Washington Post article as commenting:  "From all over the world we are getting letters of condolence, the Red Cross has come, but the so-called Great White Father in Washington hasn't said or done a thing.   When people's children are murdered and others are in the hospital hanging on to life, he should be the first one to offer his condolences. . . . If this was a white community, I don't think he'd have any problem doing that."    [3-25-05]

Resources for end-of-life issues

As the impending end of Terri Schiavo's life moves many people to think about similar situations that might one day face them, we offer some listings of helpful resources for dealing with end-of-life issues, living wills, and more.     [3-25-05]

More on "the Schiavo case"

We recently received a note urging us to provide some serious moral and theological reflection on the tragic case of Terri Schiavo.

Read the note >>

Here are more reflections, first from Witherspoon Issues Analyst Gene TeSelle, then a press release from Americans United, and finally an analysis of media coverage, by the Columbia Journalism Review.   [3-23-05]

As the impending end of Terri Schiavo's life moves many people to think about similar situations that might one day face them, we offer some listings of helpful resources for dealing with end-of-life issues, living wills, and more.   [3-25-05]

And of course, We welcome your comments!
Just send a note to be shared here.

Witherspoon member Dean Lindsey asks for reflection on the tragic and conflict-laden case of Terri Schiavo -- and he offers some opening thoughts

[3-21-05]

Dear Doug King,

I think we need some serious and pastoral and theological attention given to the Schiavo case. All of us who are pastors have stood beside many family members who have wrestled with these terribly difficult issues of when and how to treat a critically ill loved one, and whether to withhold treatment. We have also prayed and watched as these beloved ones have died, sometimes after life-support, including feeding tubes, has been withdrawn.

The situation of the Schiavo family is horribly tragic. Unfortunately, there are deep fractures within the family. We can only guess at what sort of dynamics drove them to the point that their dispute had to be played out in the courts, the press and the legislative arena. None of these is the best place to deal with such issues. Attempting to adjudicate them in the press or in a National legislative body would seem to be the absolute worst places to reach a meaningful decision.

I find it disheartening to hear the kind of rhetoric which is so heedlessly tossed about by some who claim to be speaking with a Christian voice. They have called the husband a "killer" and a "murderer." Cruelly and perhaps libelously, they speculate about his motives [seeming to ask] "Is it greed or selfishness that is driving him?"

Well, it may just be love that keeps him going. Apparently that is a possibility that the judge and the physicians in the case are willing to entertain. No doubt they have studied all the angles more carefully than any of us on the outside ever will. Still, for those efforts, they have been labeled "evil," "venal," and worse.

It is hard to imagine any possible good which can come from vilifying family members and professionals who, in their best judgment of the facts, with care for the patient and concern for their dignity, choose to terminate death-postponing, medical interventions.

It must be remembered that inserting the feeding tube was a surgical intervention to deal with a moment of crisis. Mrs. Schiavo injured herself (she was anorexic and threw off her potassium balance by bingeing and purging). Because of brain stem damage, she could no longer feed herself and probably could not swallow. The tube was inserted to forestall death at that very moment in order to give her body and mind the opportunity to heal. Her brain has not healed and she has existed in a persistent, vegetative state for 15 years.

One could say that the insertion of the feeding tube stayed the hand of God, that she was meant to die those many years ago. Now all that is left is an empty shell. Others might say that the feeding tube accomplishes the work of God, preserving this life, however faint, for some further act. Which of these two positions is correct? I would never presume to answer that question. However, I would also never dare to heap scorn on someone who would answer the question differently than me.

Might we pray for the Schiavo family and all families who deal with such intractable crises?

Surely, as Christians, we should be able to acknowledge that there are things worse than death. Indeed, the very center of our proclamation is that our earthly body is not the completion of our existence. "It is sown in dishonor, it is raised in glory." This is, after all, the season in which we celebrate resurrection. The longed-for reunion between Mrs. Schiavo's parents and a daughter who is vibrant and whole may have to wait for heaven. Is that such a bad thing to hope for, and live towards?

I'd love to have your feedback.

In Christ,

Dean Lindsey
Salem, VA

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

We welcome your comments!
Just send a note to be shared here.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 

A political take on the situation:  It's a "midnight coup" in Washington


The L. A. Times comments on the intervention of Congress and the President as a "midnight coup," short-circuiting the role of states and their courts, thus merely imposing a right-wing interpretation of morality on the nation.

When conservatives convened Congress over the weekend to pass a bill to assign jurisdiction over the Schiavo case from the Florida state judiciary to the 11th Federal Circuit, they showed their cards. The GOP is not interested in states' rights or federalism, but merely imposing a right-wing interpretation of morality on the nation. The L.A. Times stands up and calls this action what it is: part of a rolling coup against the Constitution. (L.A. Times, free registration required.)

Thanks to TomPaine.common sense

 
 

A major
Ghost Ranch event this summer!

July 28 - August 3, 2008

Paths toward Peace and Justice:

Spirituality, Earth-Care, and the Prophetic Word in a time of Violence

More info >>

 

If you like what you find here,
we hope you'll help us keep this website going ... and growing!

Please consider making a special contribution -- large or small -- to help us continue and improve this service.

Click here to send a gift online, using your credit card, through PayPal.

Or send your check, made out to "Witherspoon Society" and marked "web site," to our Witherspoon  Bookkeeper:

Susan Robertson  
9650 Clover Circle
Eden Prairie, MN  55347

 

An index of our reports from

 

 

 

BECOMING NEIGHBORS:
An Invitation
to Global Discipleship

A Witherspoon conference
on global mission and justice

September 16 - 19, 2007
Louisville, Kentucky

 

Check out our report from the Conference
on
Terror, Torture,
and Security

 

To top

© 2007 by The Witherspoon Society.  All material on this site is the responsibility of the WebWeaver unless other sources are acknowledged.  Unless otherwise noted, material on this site may be copied for personal use and sharing in small groups.  For permission to reproduce material for wider publication, please contact the WebWeaver, Doug King.  Any material reached by links on this site is outside the control and responsibility of the WebWeaver and The Witherspoon Society.  Questions or comments?  Please send a note!